Thoughtpick: A unique perspective of the Web and social media...
A unique perspective of the Web and social media...

March 12, 2009

Facebook vs. Animal Shelters!

We can find a community almost everywhere! Nature is a great example of a wide range of different communities; take beehives as one example and a herd of sheep as another… But what factors transform a community into a social network?

While pondering on the idea of social networking, over and over again, I found this thought to be interesting: Animal shelters and how similar they are to our social networking environments, especially when comparing it to Facebook!

The following table explains it all!

Animal Shelter Facebook
Animals hunted and captured by Animal Control Users hunted and captured by peer pressure and the desire to “fit in”.
Animals stay because they are trapped in a cage and need to find a home & to be fed People stay because they are trapped in the metaphorical cage of needing to find love, friendships & entertainment
The cleanliness of the shelter is necessary for the well being of the animals The user-friendly platform is necessary to attract people to subscribe to the network & use it constantly
One size fits all cage, made from the same material to retain all animals Customized “cages” depending on what the user chooses his/her privacy settings to be! Example: Facebook and limited profile.
Building uncommon relationships between animals of different breeds. Example: Youtube clip Initiating unusual relationships through networks such as dating sites, crossing geographical and ethnic boundaries
Can animal shelters reserve animal rights and not be regarded as property, or used as food, clothing, research subjects, or entertainment? Will the future give us more examples to how some social networking sites treat us merely as page views and marketing sheep (maaaa)?
There are many type of shelters such as Open door centers, animal sanctuaries and such. Many different social networking sites are available such as dating websites, Facebook, LinkedIn etc.
The sad element is when no one claims or tries to adopt the animals The sad element is when people lose hope when they finally realize that most of their online relationships are of weak ties (on thin ice), and very few are of real value!
Animals are injured, diseased or even die sometimes from overpopulation Will greed or overpopulation end the era of Facebook?

So, did Facebook really become a prison/cage? And are single users able to break this chain by simply deciding to not use Facebook? Can peer-pressure keep playing its role in trapping users into Facebook’s social maze?

I urge you to think about that!

(written by Beirut)

  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • StumbleUpon
  • Sphinn
  • Slashdot
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Mixx
  • Ping.fm
  • FriendFeed
  • BlinkList
  • Technorati
  • HackerNews
  • email

Possibly related posts:

  1. The Facebook Trap!
  2. Is Facebook Being Jinxed?
  3. Facebook protesters, you’ve got punked!
  4. Should Twitter, Youtube & Facebook be Banned from the Workplace?
  5. Facebook COO Sheryl Sandberg: Facebook is different than Twitter! [video]
Amer Kawar: Founder of ThoughtPick, a 2009 start-up "aiming to make the Internet a smoother surf". Based on a profound interest in information and technology, Amer was able to nourish this interest through studying at the University of Liverpool and graduating with a Bachelor's degree in Electrical Engineering followed by a Masters degree in Computer Network Security.
  • One more thing I need to emphasize:


    I chose to compare Facebook to an animal shelter for a few reasons... Kindly read below:



    1. We need to step out of the norms and be creative in our approach to any subject and after reading many articles speaking of Facebook and social networking, I felt the need for something that could spark an interest... Something unusual and different...



    2. I very well believe that any community, whether it be an animal, plant or human community, shares many factors and characteristics with other communities which allows us to easily compare and contrast.



    3. The web, in my opinion, is an online reality which was extracted from society and could easily be traced back to it.



    4. "Great minds think alike..." Or do they? :) I think great minds have the ability to think differently about different topics and in return make conclusions and assumptions based on what the mind sees and what the logic defines...



    Thank you again!
  • Dear Fadi... first of all, thank you for your comments and feedback...


    Now, let me tell you a story...



    http://thoughtpickers.blogspot.com/2009/03/facebook-trap.html
  • That is true for people with strong ties, such as friends, relatives and work colleagues. But for people you met on the Facebook, whom you have just one shared conversation or comment per month, you would be losing this weak tie by closing your Facebook account.
    That's my opinion at least :)
  • But it is not something you do against you well. I know many friends who had accounts and then decided to shut it down for various social reasons.


    Peer-pressure can get you excited about checking it out, but it is not in anyway a force to trap you in. Still online social networks is an *alternative* way of communication. People still have their offline social interactions.
  • Also, you cannot leave Facebook (or other well known social sites) because your friends now have it as a way of getting in touch with you. The same reason why you do not suddenly change an email address or a mobile number!
  • Well, I don't agree that peer-pressure is not an issue, as it was the main reason I got on Facebook.
    From my personal experience, when 7 out of 10 close friends keep talking about Facebook, what games they are playing on it, and what funny comments they wrote on one another's photos, you (or me in this case) as a third-party, become alienated from this social conversation. That was why I joined!
  • I don't really like this comparison as I don't think that peer pressure is enough obligatory reason for anyone to stay in an online social network.


    The reason of the success of online social networks is the need of human beings to socialize and communicate and create new bonds. It is not in anyway or form a prison for humans where they can't break out like animal shelters for animals. Freedom to do what you want is essential for anyone to have a sense of belonging in a certain community.



    A better comparison would be comparing a human online community interaction with a closer look of the way champanzies interact in their social networks.
blog comments powered by Disqus