Dell vs. Toshiba – Death Match via Youtube, Facebook & Twitter…

Is social media turning into one of the main reasons for purchasing trendy, fashionable and tech products these days? Could a brand’s wrong utilization of social media affect its image negatively? Is it fair to solely depend on web marketing and social media channels (such as Youtube, Twitter and Facebook) in order to decide whether to purchase a certain brand or its competitor?

A month or more ago, I published an article about Blackberry Storm vs. iPhone 3G. I noticed that our readers really enjoyed this type of topics. Therefore, the ThoughtPick team, and after an idea-loaded brainstorming session, decided to turn this type of posts into a series: Social Media & Web Marketing Wars!

A Little Bit of History…

Before moving on to evaluating the effectiveness of their social media utilization, it is only fair to talk a little about Dell and Toshiba’s histories.

Let’s begin with Dell. Dell was established in 1984 by Michael Dell and it employs more than 76,500 people worldwide as of 2009. “Dell grew during the 1980s and 1990s to become (for a time) the largest seller of PCs and servers. As of 2008 it held the second spot in computer-sales within the industry behind Hewlett-Packard. The company currently sells personal computers, servers, data storage devices, network switches, software, and computer peripherals”.

As for Toshiba, it was founded by the merging of two companies in 1939. Toshiba America Information Systems was created in 1989. “Toshiba is the world’s fifth largest personal computer manufacturer, after Hewlett-Packard and Dell of the U.S., Acer of Taiwan and Lenovo of China.

Dell & Toshiba… “Social Medially”!

As a crucial part of my research, I made an effort to cover 4 important aspects of Dell and Toshiba’s online presence, especially when it comes to social media platforms: Twitter, Youtube, Facebook and Blogs.

1. Twitter:

What does Dell conduct itself on Twitter?

Dell seems to very well understand the power that Twitter is able to equip it with and appears to be doing the most it can to reap the benefits of having a strong presence as a Twitter user:

So, how is Toshiba using Twitter?

As I see it, and based on my humble research, it seems to me that Toshiba doesn’t take Twitter that seriously:

  • Toshiba has 2 Twitter accounts: A main one for all its products and another Toshiba Laptops account. The total number of followers on both accounts does not exceed 2,000 followers.
  • Moreover, the last status update for one of the accounts was on August 4th, while the one before was July 16th!

2. Facebook:

How does Dell deal with Facebook?

Well, apparently, Dell is also very active on Facebook as well!

  • Dell has a few Facebook pages for its consumer products and website and a couple more for its general products as well. The main 2 pages have a total of around 60,000 fans! Furthermore, their Consumer Products Page has loads of posts, ads and promotions for people to follow up and engage in through comments.
  • As for the groups, Dell also has a few groups on Facebook with a total of around 2,000 members.

From Dell's Fan Page

From Dell's Fan Page

Now, what is Toshiba doing on Facebook in return?

Again, through the same clicks and searches around Facebook, I was not rally impressed with the results I have found for Toshiba on Facebook as it seems to be not-too-Facebook-friendly either!

  • Although Toshiba does have Facebook pages and groups, but the total number of fans and members in all of them does not exceed 4,000 with Toshiba Satellite’s page either being very new or just simply inactive!

3. YouTube:

Alrighty then! Let’s take a look on how Dell is doing as opposed to Toshiba when it comes to ads posted on Youtube in terms of innovation and viral factor!

Please note that I just compared 2 recent ads for Dell and Toshiba (posted July, 2009).

Dell on Youtube… Keep the ads rolling!

I’d have to raise my hat for Dell’s latest ad on Youtube “The Lollipop” TV Commercial! Not only is it creative and unique, it also is guaranteed to make you smile and bring you closer to the brand even if you choose not to purchase the product! Up to this date, this ad earned over 9,000 Youtube views.

Was Toshiba able to beat or at least meet that?

I have to give it up to Toshiba for the ad they have on Youtube, “No Matter What Your New Toshiba Will Survive“! Kudos for the incredible touch of humor and clever product and brand marketing! Alas, it seems to have gone to waste with a total of only 857 Youtube views!

4. Blogs:

Logically, one one assume that what Toshiba lacked to achieve on other social media platforms, it would make up by having a specialized blog to share news with its customers, display promotions and effectively reply to consumer questions and concerns. But that’s not the case!

After a short Google search, I was able to locate Dell’s blog very easily! The blog is very helpful, easy to browse, informative and customer friendly! Taking the same amount of time, I was just able to find some kind of blog for Toshiba, jammed with ads and clutters of information!

A final word to our readers…

What can Toshiba do better? The answer is rather simple: walk Dell’s footsteps! A bit harsh? Well, yes it might be but I am a true believer that if someone else can do it, so can you! So Toshiba, why not be more engaged with consumers via social media platforms, tools and channels? Why accept to be beaten at a game that could be easily done with a little bit more open mindedness, dynamism and interactivity?

What more do you think Toshiba can do, can you offer them some further advice? And which brand do you favor: Dell or Toshiba?

Comments and Reactions

  • Guest

    Wait. This is analysis? You set this by making a series of questions which you never answer: other than to compare Dell's robust subscriber/follower counts to Toshiba's anemic ones, but you never cross correlate those to relative marketshare …..

    Feh. This is like Queer Eye for the Socially Challenged Brand – let's spruce up your Twitter feed and get your Facebook profile some new jeans …….

  • http://blog.thoughtpick.com Amer Kawar

    Well, the aim of this analysis was to compare the social media and web marketing aspect of those 2 brands, so relative market shares was not the point we were attempting to cover… thus the name of the series “Social Media & Web Marketing Wars”.

    Regarding the questions, we are attempting to encourage you, as our reader, to think of your last Dell or Toshiba purchase, and tell us if social media affected your decision. Did it?

  • http://blog.thoughtpick.com/ FadiPick

    Dell is certainly performing better thank Toshiba in the social arena, no wonder I have a better perception of their brand. I like your final advice, Toshiba should literally follow Dell's footsteps – I totally second that!

  • Griff

    I've just done a little search and I have to say whilst I found a lot of Youtube videos about Toshiba notebooks, with the exception of the one about the guarantee that you already highlighted, few if any would entice me to buy. I am a big Toshiba fan having worked for the company (I also worked for Dell for a while). The thing is this, working out what works for me as a prospective buyer. Reliability scores would be good, connectivity, warranty, ability (ie don't tell me about dual core AMD processing, tell me what it will enable me to do). I don't want to see a screenshot of the battery or the hard disk as I assume it will have those, I want to know storage sizes and I want to know battery life – under NORMAL use conditions!

  • Guest

    I think the person above's point is that if you look at the percentage of followers versus market share, you might find that 1% of Dell's buyers follow them socially, while 3% of Toshiba's do. (These are just made-up numbers, but you see my point – it gives more depth to the same information.) Nobody will argue that Dell has a lot of resources engaged in the social space – but this article may have been more helpful if it gauged success across more than just user counts.

  • http://blog.thoughtpick.com/2009/09/mac-snow-leopard-vs-microsoft-windows-7-on-youtube-twitter-facebook-blogs.html Mac Snow Leopard vs. Microsoft Windows 7 on Youtube, Twitter, Facebook & Blogs… | Thoughtpick Blog

    [...] as I did in the previous social media wars episodes (Blackberry Storm Vs. iPhone 3G) and (Dell vs. Toshiba), this post will entail a detailed study of the use of social media to promote Mac’s Snow [...]

  • http://blog.thoughtpick.com/2009/09/follower-trafficking-would-you-sell-your-twitter-followers-discreetly.html Follower Trafficking: Would You Sell Your Twitter Followers – Discreetly? | Thoughtpick Blog

    [...] your user name, your avatar or background, or even just to promote to you certain links, beliefs, products or services that may actually be of interest to you. But at the end of the day, it was you whom [...]

  • http://www.titidirectonline.co.uk/ski-snowboard-goggles Ski Goggles

    nice post

  • http://www.electrocomputerwarehouse.com/ cheap computers

    The thing is this, working out what works for me as a prospective buyer. Reliability scores would be good, connectivity, warranty and ability.

  • http://www.bluemedica.com/sculptra.php sculptra

    Dell is an American-based international, diversified information-technology supplier that mostly trades in Computer and technology-related products and services. Dell deals in the range of products that caters to both Business Class and Consumer Class. Some of the products developed by Dell are – Personal computers, Software, servers, data storage devices, televisions, network switches, computer peripherals and many other technology-related products.

  • http://www.laptopbatteriesinc.com.au/laptop-battery/dell/dell-inspiron-6000-battery Dell Inspiron 6000 battery

    Dell, an IT company famous for the ease of purchasing computers has completely dropped the ball with this laptop from the design to the service. It is truly unbelievable.

  • http://www.laptopreviews2u.com/hp-pavilion-dv6-3013nr-review-hp-pavilion-dv6-3013nr-15-6-inch-laptop-argento/ Udd99

    Reliability scores would be good, connectivity, warranty, ability (ie don't tell me about dual core AMD processing, tell me what it will enable me to do) Thank for sharing.

  • http://www.laptopreviews2u.com/toshiba-satellite-l655-s5112-review-toshiba-satellite-l655-s5112-15-6-inch-led-laptop-fusion-finish-in-helios-black/ Uddy

    This is like Queer Eye for the Socially Challenged Brand – let's spruce up your Twitter feed and get your Facebook profile.

  • Susan Smith

    Its all
    together two different websites, Facebook is a social networking site and you
    tube is a video sharing site. However the only link between facebook and you
    tube is, we can share the same video as seen on youtube in facebook as well.
    Cheers,
    Susan Smith,
    promodirect.com

  • http://virusremovalhelps.com/help-system-fix-virus-removal/ remove system fix virus

    Word of mouth is very important, especially in social networks.

  • http://www.getdailyviews.com/ youtube play increaser

    Great stuff! Thanks for the share. Very simple yet effective tips

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest pingbacks

Like us on Facebook

We love Tweepi

Tweepi Logo

Follow the best and unfollow the bots, with the only Twitter management tool with stats!

Big Advert

Share a post

Got an amazing campaign, web app or a social media related topic that you'd like to share with our readers?

Explore Thoughtpick

Our Archived Posts

Try Our #FF Helper App

FollowFriday Helper makes playing Twitter's #ff a piece of cake!

A brand new way to recommend tweeps based on how you tweet...

We're on Twitter

Oops, something went wrong and we could not display the latest tweets! :(

Thoughtpick by email

For more Learn Social Media by Example reviews, don't forget to subscribe to our posts by email:

©2010 thoughtpick, copyrights reserved.